Mis-Sold GAP Insurance? How to Claim a Refund
GAP insurance covers the gap between what you paid for a car and what your insurer pays out if it's written off. The FCA found that this product offered poor value, it identified that in some distribution chains as little as around 6% of the premium was being paid out in claims, and in 2024 firms paused or restricted sales while they improved their fair value. Many policies were also mis-sold: pushed at the point of sale, with pressure, with no time to shop around, or without explaining you could buy it cheaper elsewhere or didn't need it at all. If that happened to you, you can complain and seek a refund.
Skip the writing, get your claim in 15 seconds.
We'll draft a firm, ready-to-send demand tailored to your situation. Free.
Build my claim →Your rights
GAP insurance is a regulated insurance product, so its sale falls under the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) rules, including the requirement to treat customers fairly and the Consumer Duty (in force since 31 July 2023) to deliver fair value and avoid foreseeable harm. The FCA's ICOBS rules require that a product is suitable and clearly explained. If GAP was sold to you with high-pressure tactics, bundled without a real choice, sold at a price far above its value, or without disclosing that standalone cover was far cheaper, you may have grounds to say it was mis-sold. Complain first to the firm that sold it (the dealer or the insurer). They have up to 8 weeks to respond. If they reject you or don't reply in time, you can refer the complaint free to the Financial Ombudsman Service (FOS) within 6 months of their final response. The FOS can order a refund of premiums plus 8% simple interest.
Step by step
- 1Dig out your paperwork: the GAP policy document, the finance or sale agreement, and any record of what you were told at the point of sale. Note the price you paid and whether you were given time to consider it or told you could buy elsewhere.
- 2Write a formal complaint to the seller (the dealer) and/or the GAP insurer. State clearly why you believe it was mis-sold, e.g. pressured sale, no explanation of cheaper alternatives, poor value, or that it was unsuitable for you, and request a full refund of the premium.
- 3Give them up to 8 weeks to issue a final response. Keep copies of everything and a note of all phone calls.
- 4If they reject your complaint or don't respond within 8 weeks, escalate free to the Financial Ombudsman Service within 6 months of their final response. Provide your evidence and the firm's response.
What they'll say, and your comeback
“You signed the agreement, so you accepted the product.”
Comeback, A signature doesn't make a sale fair. Under FCA rules and the Consumer Duty, the firm had to ensure the product was suitable, fairly priced and clearly explained. If it was pressured, bundled or sold without disclosing cheaper alternatives, your signature doesn't bar a mis-selling complaint.
“GAP is a useful product and was a reasonable price.”
Comeback, The FCA itself found GAP offered poor value, identifying that in some cases as little as around 6% of premiums were paid out in claims, and firms paused or restricted sales in 2024 over fair-value concerns. The test is whether it was suitable and fairly sold to you, not whether the product exists in general. The Ombudsman can rule on that.
“Too much time has passed to complain.”
Comeback, There is generally no fixed cut-off for raising a mis-selling complaint with the firm. The 6-month limit only runs from the firm's final response to your complaint, and the Ombudsman's 6-year rule runs from the event or from when you reasonably became aware of the problem.
FAQ
How much could I get back?
If your complaint succeeds you can be refunded the premium you paid, typically with 8% simple interest added for the time you were out of pocket. If the policy is still running it may instead be cancelled with a pro-rata refund.
Does it cost anything to use the Financial Ombudsman?
No. The Financial Ombudsman Service is free for consumers. You send the complaint yourself and keep 100% of any refund. You do not need a claims management company.
Ready to get your money back?
Reclaim it now, free →More money you might be owed
- UKHow to Challenge a Rejected Home Insurance Claim
- UKInsurer Undervalued Your Written-Off Car? How to Challenge It
- UKHow to challenge a rejected pet insurance claim
- UKHow to reclaim a mis-sold payment protection style add-on
- UKHow to reclaim a rejected mobile phone insurance claim
- UKHow to get a refund for a faulty product (even 'out of policy')
A self-serve tool, not a law firm. General information, not legal advice.